The brief said reduce cost. The real problem was somewhere else.

A coastline silhouetted at sunset

The most expensive part of this engine wasn’t in the engine.

An automotive company invited us to run a value study on one of its engine systems. The brief was clear: reduce the overall cost of the engine system by 10%.

It is one of the most common briefs we receive, and it sounds straightforward. But one of the first things a value study does is look at the whole picture before deciding where to focus. In this case, that changed everything.

Following the cost beyond the factory

When the team gathered the information on what the engine really cost the company, the cost of making it was only part of the story. Packaging and logistics costs were high. And on top of them sat a much bigger number: warranty claims.

So the team followed it. Why were there so many claims?

The answer was simple and expensive. Engines were arriving at customers damaged, with a part broken. To fix this, the company sent a vendor to the customer’s site to repair each one. Because customers were spread across many locations, the company needed many different vendors in many different places. Every damaged delivery added cost, and the overall profit from the product kept falling.

No amount of savings on materials or machining would have solved that. The company could have made the engine cheaper to build and still lost money on every one that arrived broken.

The real cause was in the design

As the team analysed the engine, it became clear why the part was breaking. The cause was not careless handling or a poor supplier. It was in the basic design of the engine itself, its geometry and how robust it was.

That was not an easy conclusion to accept. The design was a legacy design, and there was strong resistance to changing it. This is very natural. A design that has been in production for years carries a lot of history, and people trust what they know.

What moved the discussion was the cost of the warranty claims. Once the team could see what the existing design was really costing the business, every damaged delivery and every vendor visit, the case for change became much harder to argue with.

Two studies, one problem

We ran two value studies. One looked at the engine itself: its geometry and robustness. The other looked at logistics: packaging design and how the engines were stacked and shipped.

The results went well beyond the 10% target:

  • 30% lower product cost, through a rigorous geometric redesign of the engine.
  • 53% lower logistics cost, through better pack design, stacking and transport routing.
  • 95% fewer damaged deliveries.

The last result is the one I find most telling. Nobody set out to fix damaged deliveries as a target of its own. It came from making the product and its packaging work together. The redesigned engine was more compact and more robust, which made better packaging possible, and the better packaging protected a better engine.

That is often how value works. When you solve the right problem, the benefits spread. When you solve the wrong one, you can spend a great deal of effort and see very little change.

Why the brief is only the starting point

This study is a good example of why the Value Methodology does not start with ideas. It starts with information and with understanding what the product actually has to do.

If the team had taken the brief at face value, it would have looked for ways to make the engine cheaper to manufacture. It might even have found some. But the damaged deliveries would have continued, the vendors would still have been travelling to customers, and the product would still have been losing money.

The brief tells you what the organisation thinks the problem is. The study’s job is to find out what the problem really is.

A question worth asking

If your organisation is under pressure to reduce the cost of a product, it is worth asking one question before anything else: what is this product really costing us, from the factory floor to the customer and beyond?

Sometimes the answer is exactly where you expected. Often it is not.

If you suspect your product’s real cost sits somewhere other than the bill of materials, talk to us about a value study.